Political philosophy
A.A. 2018/2019
Obiettivi formativi
In terms of content, we will be primarily concerned with questions of freedom, justice and political authority. Questions of political authority are concerned with why and to what extent a political authority has legitimate power over us. Do governments derive their authority from 'the consent of the governed'? If so, what does that consent look like? Can the state do anything it wants to us, or are there limits? If there are limits, where do those limits come from? Moreover, the course aims to highlight how political philosophy is relevant, especially in times of crisis, where it becomes imperative to find and implement some new shared criteria of judgment. Then it calls for critical clarification of and reflection on the most fundamental terms of our political life, and suggests new possibilities for the future. What is distinctive about political philosophy is its prescriptive or evaluative concern, in short, its concern with how political societies should be, how policies and institutions can be justified, how we and our political leaders ought to behave in our public lives. What does a justifiable or legitimate political order involve?
In terms of method, students will also learn various skills in philosophic methodology:
- Students will learn how to read philosophic texts. The readings for this course consist entirely of primary sources, and we will spend most of our class periods with the text close at hand, going over it line-by-line in many cases;
- Students will learn the skills of conceptual analysis and philosophic argumentation. Much time will be spent in this course getting clear about distinctions between closely related concepts (justice, fairness, desert, needs, etc.);
- Students will learn to understand and discuss coherently the foundational issues listed in the course description;
- Students will be expected both to be able to analyze the arguments of other philosophers, and to forge new arguments of your own.
To sum up, the general aims of this course are the following:
· To help students to improve their ability to read carefully, write and speak clearly, and think analytically;
· To allow the students to gain a critical understanding of some of the most important issues and theories in Political Philosophy;
· To enhance students' knowledge of central terms of political theory and sharpen their conceptual skills to identify, compare and evaluate philosophical arguments;
· To develop students critical thinking skills needed to compare, evaluate and analyze philosophical arguments within the field of political theory.
· To gain a more complete and refined understanding of students theoretical commitments in the political realm (or - in the absence of such commitments -, to help generate them).
· To see the connections between philosophical contributions to political thought and the actual political arrangements of our time.
In terms of method, students will also learn various skills in philosophic methodology:
- Students will learn how to read philosophic texts. The readings for this course consist entirely of primary sources, and we will spend most of our class periods with the text close at hand, going over it line-by-line in many cases;
- Students will learn the skills of conceptual analysis and philosophic argumentation. Much time will be spent in this course getting clear about distinctions between closely related concepts (justice, fairness, desert, needs, etc.);
- Students will learn to understand and discuss coherently the foundational issues listed in the course description;
- Students will be expected both to be able to analyze the arguments of other philosophers, and to forge new arguments of your own.
To sum up, the general aims of this course are the following:
· To help students to improve their ability to read carefully, write and speak clearly, and think analytically;
· To allow the students to gain a critical understanding of some of the most important issues and theories in Political Philosophy;
· To enhance students' knowledge of central terms of political theory and sharpen their conceptual skills to identify, compare and evaluate philosophical arguments;
· To develop students critical thinking skills needed to compare, evaluate and analyze philosophical arguments within the field of political theory.
· To gain a more complete and refined understanding of students theoretical commitments in the political realm (or - in the absence of such commitments -, to help generate them).
· To see the connections between philosophical contributions to political thought and the actual political arrangements of our time.
Risultati apprendimento attesi
Non definiti
Periodo: Primo trimestre
Modalità di valutazione: Esame
Giudizio di valutazione: voto verbalizzato in trentesimi
Corso singolo
Questo insegnamento non può essere seguito come corso singolo. Puoi trovare gli insegnamenti disponibili consultando il catalogo corsi singoli.
Programma e organizzazione didattica
Edizione unica
Responsabile
Periodo
Primo trimestre
STUDENTI FREQUENTANTI
Prerequisiti
Course requirements for attendant students:
ATTENDANCE: attendance is compulsory and it will be taken at the beginning of each class. It is the responsibility of student to be sure that his/her attendance has been recorded. More than three unexcused absences may cause a grade of fail. In the case of illness or an emergency situation, official documentation must be provided to grant an excused absence.
PARTICIPATION: all assigned readings should be read prior to coming to class. Each student is expected to contribute to the discussion, and thus each student is expected to be prepared to ask questions and discuss the assigned readings on each day, and whether or not the student is presenting that day.
PRESENTATION: students will also be responsible for doing presentations of the readings at least one time during the course. Presentations should briefly summarize methodological positions and philosophical arguments of the readings. Nevertheless, the main part of presentation will be critical discussion of the viewpoints raised by the readings.
FINAL QUESTION PAPER: the final test may address any of the issues specified on this class schedule, and consist of true/false, multiple choice and short questions. This test is due on the last day of the class and must be your own work. Plagiarism is grounds for failure of the course. Plagiarism includes the use of someone else's ideas or words without giving the appropriate reference or credit.
GRADING: Student performance will be evaluated as follows:
Final Question Paper 40%
Presentation 35%
Class Participation 25%
ATTENDANCE: attendance is compulsory and it will be taken at the beginning of each class. It is the responsibility of student to be sure that his/her attendance has been recorded. More than three unexcused absences may cause a grade of fail. In the case of illness or an emergency situation, official documentation must be provided to grant an excused absence.
PARTICIPATION: all assigned readings should be read prior to coming to class. Each student is expected to contribute to the discussion, and thus each student is expected to be prepared to ask questions and discuss the assigned readings on each day, and whether or not the student is presenting that day.
PRESENTATION: students will also be responsible for doing presentations of the readings at least one time during the course. Presentations should briefly summarize methodological positions and philosophical arguments of the readings. Nevertheless, the main part of presentation will be critical discussion of the viewpoints raised by the readings.
FINAL QUESTION PAPER: the final test may address any of the issues specified on this class schedule, and consist of true/false, multiple choice and short questions. This test is due on the last day of the class and must be your own work. Plagiarism is grounds for failure of the course. Plagiarism includes the use of someone else's ideas or words without giving the appropriate reference or credit.
GRADING: Student performance will be evaluated as follows:
Final Question Paper 40%
Presentation 35%
Class Participation 25%
Materiale di riferimento
STUDENTI NON FREQUENTANTI
Syllabus - Democracy and Disobedience
Week One: Introduction to Political Philosophy
What is political philosophy?
"The Allegory of the Cave", Plato (Republic, VII);
"Four Roles of Political Philosophy", J. Rawls (Justice as Fairness. A Restatement, chap. I);
"Walking out of the Cave", M. Walzer (Spheres of Justice, Preface);
"The Practice of Social Criticism", M. Walzer (The Company of the Critics, Preface);
Week Two: Introduction to Political Philosophy
Apology of Socrates, Plato ;
Week Three: Obey and Disobey
Crito, Plato
Week Four: Presentations and Discussion
Week Five: Civil Disobedience
Martin Luther King, Jr., "A Letter from the Birmingham Jail," in Why We Can't Wait (1963), pp. 77-100;
John Rawls, A Theory of Justice (1999 [1971]), pp. 319-343 (§§ 55-59);
Week Six: Civil Disobedience
Peter Singer: "Disobedience as a Plea for Reconsideration";
Joseph Raz, "Authority and Justification," Philosophy & Public Affairs 14:1 (1985), pp. 3-29;
Ronald Dworkin, "Civil Disobedience and Nuclear Protest," in A Matter of Principle (1985), pp. 104-116, 404;
Week Seven: (Un)civil Disobedience ?
John Morreal: "The Justifiability of Violent Civil Disobedience", Canadian Journal of Philosophy, Vol. 6, No. 1 (Mar., 1976), pp. 35-47;
A.John Simmons: "Justification and Legitimacy", Ethics, Vol. 109, No. 4 (July 1999), pp. 739-771;
Week Eight: Presentations and Discussion
Week Nine: Contemporary Perspectives on Civil Disobedience
Week Ten: Presentations and Discussion
The course is organized around some topics for a total amount of 20 lectures. Each reading is compulsory, and has to be completed before the lecture. The updated reading list will be regularly provided on the web pages of the course on Ariel and students are more than warmly invited to have a look at it. Some issues - the issues in yellow - imply your explicit active presentation and discussion.
In most of the cases, readings can be retrieved directly in the website of the course.
*Please note that on this course Syllabus additional readings could be added. Need help? Feel free to talk with me after class, during office hours, or by arrangement.
Week One: Introduction to Political Philosophy
What is political philosophy?
"The Allegory of the Cave", Plato (Republic, VII);
"Four Roles of Political Philosophy", J. Rawls (Justice as Fairness. A Restatement, chap. I);
"Walking out of the Cave", M. Walzer (Spheres of Justice, Preface);
"The Practice of Social Criticism", M. Walzer (The Company of the Critics, Preface);
Week Two: Introduction to Political Philosophy
Apology of Socrates, Plato ;
Week Three: Obey and Disobey
Crito, Plato
Week Four: Presentations and Discussion
Week Five: Civil Disobedience
Martin Luther King, Jr., "A Letter from the Birmingham Jail," in Why We Can't Wait (1963), pp. 77-100;
John Rawls, A Theory of Justice (1999 [1971]), pp. 319-343 (§§ 55-59);
Week Six: Civil Disobedience
Peter Singer: "Disobedience as a Plea for Reconsideration";
Joseph Raz, "Authority and Justification," Philosophy & Public Affairs 14:1 (1985), pp. 3-29;
Ronald Dworkin, "Civil Disobedience and Nuclear Protest," in A Matter of Principle (1985), pp. 104-116, 404;
Week Seven: (Un)civil Disobedience ?
John Morreal: "The Justifiability of Violent Civil Disobedience", Canadian Journal of Philosophy, Vol. 6, No. 1 (Mar., 1976), pp. 35-47;
A.John Simmons: "Justification and Legitimacy", Ethics, Vol. 109, No. 4 (July 1999), pp. 739-771;
Week Eight: Presentations and Discussion
Week Nine: Contemporary Perspectives on Civil Disobedience
Week Ten: Presentations and Discussion
The course is organized around some topics for a total amount of 20 lectures. Each reading is compulsory, and has to be completed before the lecture. The updated reading list will be regularly provided on the web pages of the course on Ariel and students are more than warmly invited to have a look at it. Some issues - the issues in yellow - imply your explicit active presentation and discussion.
In most of the cases, readings can be retrieved directly in the website of the course.
*Please note that on this course Syllabus additional readings could be added. Need help? Feel free to talk with me after class, during office hours, or by arrangement.
Prerequisiti
Course requirements for non attendant students:
Exam
1. a written test (10 questions);
2. an oral examination, provided the written test is passed.
Exam
1. a written test (10 questions);
2. an oral examination, provided the written test is passed.
Materiale di riferimento
Democracy And Disobedience
SYLLABUS*
Program:
"The Allegory of the Cave", Plato (Republic, VII);
"Philosophy and Politics", H. Arendt;
"Four Roles of Political Philosophy", J. Rawls (Justice as Fairness. A Restatement, chap. I);
R. Grant, "Political Theory, Political Science and Politics", Political Theory, 4 (2002);
Apology of Socrates, Plato;
Gorgias, Crito;
"Civil Disobedience in Global Perspective", M. Allen, Springer, 2017.
*Please note that on this course Syllabus additional readings could be added. All the texts will be available on http://ariel.unimi.it
SYLLABUS*
Program:
"The Allegory of the Cave", Plato (Republic, VII);
"Philosophy and Politics", H. Arendt;
"Four Roles of Political Philosophy", J. Rawls (Justice as Fairness. A Restatement, chap. I);
R. Grant, "Political Theory, Political Science and Politics", Political Theory, 4 (2002);
Apology of Socrates, Plato;
Gorgias, Crito;
"Civil Disobedience in Global Perspective", M. Allen, Springer, 2017.
*Please note that on this course Syllabus additional readings could be added. All the texts will be available on http://ariel.unimi.it
Docente/i
Ricevimento:
Su appuntamento, sia in presenza sia su Teams
stanza 14 - sopralzo cortile